THE LONGEST, BLOODIEST BRAWL OF ALL
1953
The Angels rose to third place and were playing a weeklong series against the Stars. Every night game that week was hotly disputed and the vendettas, instigated by Bragan, had grown dangerous. Dad drove to Gilmore Field with Hattan and took me and a friend, Ron Bart, a huge 12 year old, a brute, a Little League all star and one of the top kids at South Park. Awaiting us was a Sunday doubleheader.
Since the games
were sold out and no seats available, Ron and I ended up behind the rope at
right field, among a bunch of Hollywood Star knothole kids who hated the
Angels, so automatically hated Ron and me. By the second inning we were having
words with them as we defended Angel players. Ropes winding from both foul
lines in the outfield were set up for the jam-packed overflow.
Early in the
first game, in retaliation for some fireworks the day before, Hattan planted
one of his infrequent fastballs in Frank Kelleher’s ribs. Kelleher, my Dad’s
friend, whom Dad said was one of the good guys, had been on a hitting tear that
was demolishing the Angel pitching staff, and he rushed to the mound and decked
Hattan, who jumped up to do battle. Players from both benches and bullpens
instantly swarmed onto the field and a skirmish started near the mound as
umpires and peacemakers eventually managed to quiet things down. Kelleher was
ejected.
While order was
being restored, several nearby kids realized my father was Murray Franklin and
began razzing me, claiming my Dad would get his ass kicked by the Stars, and
several grown-ups and an usher got between us.
Then short, wiry
Teddy Beard ran for Kelleher and stole second. When he tried to steal third the
Angels had him by five feet, and as Dad, straddling the bag, caught the ball, Beard
started his slide too close and flew into him thigh-high, spiking him on the
forearms and chest. Dad’s cap flew off, his bald head glinted in the sun, and
then his fists were working in a blur. Both dugouts and bullpens charged onto
the diamond and skirmishes whirled like spinning tops. A mountain of bodies
piled up near the mound, new bodies entering while others flew out or charged
back in; smaller skirmishes, moving, squirming, flailing, broke out all over
the infield like a runaway saloon brawl from the movies. Certain players
squared off, while others flitted around swinging wildly. While Dad was
pummeling Beard, Gordy Maltzburger, coaching third, trying to be peacemaker,
pulled Dad off Beard from behind, leaving him open for Beard to punch. Dad ducked
the punch and shrugged off Maltzburger, who was being pulled off by Stan Hack.
That was when McLish, on a full-tilt sprint from the bullpen, leveled Beard
with a vicious punch and then proceeded, as Dad described it, “to pinch the
little bastard’s head off.” Then Dad and McLish, like roving commandos, went
head-hunting, which meant trying to inflict as much pain and damage as possible
on anybody in a home uniform, be they peacemakers, friends or not. The umpires
were helpless to stop it.
Bart and I lost
track of Dad and suddenly we were engaged with the knothole kids, pummeling,
kicking, rolling around on the grass outside the ropes, until an usher and some
adults broke it up.
The donnybrook
went on and on, showed no signs of abating until, eventually, a stream of
fifty-plus LAPD cops surged onto the field to restore order. Bart and I ducked
under the rope, dodged an usher or two and sprinted across the grass toward the
action, veering into the box section of the ball park. By this time the melee
was slowing down as cops separated brawling players. Uniforms were torn and
filthy, caps lost. Ball players cursed and pointed fingers at each other as
they were led to their dugouts. The last thing we saw before ducking into a
tunnel was Dad pointing a finger and barking at the Star players as two
understanding cops led him away with half smiles.
The cop at the
clubhouse door knew me and allowed us to enter the room full of cursing,
pacing, grumbling, torn-up players vowing retaliation. Most of them refused
medical treatment. Dad was sitting on the table in the training room, the
trainer rubbing antiseptic on deep spike wounds on his chest and forearm. He’d
refused stitches until after the second game of the doubleheader, which he
intended to play. When he spotted me his face turned into a wide grin. “There’s
my boy!” I told him Ron and I fought with the knothole kids from Hollywood and he told his team mates, “Them’s fightin’ Compton boys!”
First baseman
Fuzz Richards, who’d taken the worst punishment from blindside fists and was
gouged and spiked when trapped beneath the mountainous pile-up, was getting
sewn up by a doctor—over twenty stitches in his backside. He was furious. Bud
Hardin sported a shiner and stalked the clubhouse holding an icepack to his eye
and vowing to get revenge on Dale Long. Dad began ranting about Bragan, whom he
blamed for inciting the brawl by sending Beard after him. “I don’t even know
Beard, but he came in spikes high going for my balls. Now he’s got a broken leg
and two closed eyes, and that’s what you get when you’re a dirty ball
player—he’s finished.”
Dad’s face had no
nicks, though his knuckles on both hands were bruised and cut and swelling.
Stan Hack, who, during the brawl had spent most of his time looking for Bragan,
who he claimed hid in the dugout, approached Dad at the training table. “Moe,
Bragan’s slated to catch the second game. I’m starting you and leading you off,
and I want you to call out that yellowbelly. If they run you I’ll pay the fine.
I’ll have Hardin waiting to come in for you.”
Dad grinned.
“Skip, I’ll go after him, but Bragan won’t fight—he’s a man with a paper
asshole.”
McLish, bat
perched on shoulder (he was a decent hitter who sometimes pinch-hit), standing
behind Dad, nodded, then rubbed Dad’s head as if it was Holy, and winked at me.
Second game, Ron
and I were not about to return to the ropes in right field, instead stationing
ourselves in the aisle a few rows up from the seats above home plate, ignoring
and avoiding ushers who tried to move us along. Cops were posted like sentries
at both clubhouse doors, in front of both dugouts, down both foul lines and
bull pens and along the ropes.
When Dad came to
bat every Angel was on his feet in the dugout. Dad stood there looking down on
Bragan, spewing profanity and insults, kicking dirt on the plate, on Bragan’s
spikes, while the ump stared out toward the field. Dad’s head bobbed as he
chewed on Bragan, who picked at clods of dirt, tossing them around. Finally Dad
stepped into the box, pounded his bat hard on the plate and stared at the
pitcher, Red Munger, who proceeded to walk Dad on four pitches.”
Dad said
afterwards, “I called Bragan every name in the book. I’ve never seen a man take
more shit and hunker down like a gutless coward. He tried to blame the umpires.
The ump, he was enjoying every minute—grinning like a shark. Told me he
wouldn’t run me under any circumstances. I told Bragan we were ON if Munger
came anywhere near me—for Hack. Munger’s an old hand, he knew what was going
on. He threw me four straight pitches a foot outside. Bragan’s all mouth.”
The second game
was uneventful. Next day L.A.
sports pages quoted Bragan blaming the umpires for the brawl. Sportswriters
reported the bloodiest, most prolonged brawl perhaps in baseball history. The
front pages were full of photos, as were the back pages; the most prominent in
all the papers and later in Life Magazine was one of Beard flying at Dad with
his spikes high, like swords, his face contorted like a kamikaze, while Dad
waited, ball in glove. The articles were full of descriptions, quotes,
commentary, and already scribes were trying to drum up a return bout in the
next series between the two teams at Wrigley, where LAPD Chief William Parker
vowed to preside over a legion of cops to keep the peace. Beard’s season was
ended with a broken ankle. Dad got stitched up and I don’t think I’ve ever seen
him happier.
“I’m not one to
condone it, but dammit sometimes fighting is a good thing. It clears out your
tubes.”
(Next
installment: Big Moe Faces “Bear Tracks” Greer in the Texas League)